Billy Crystal’s ‘Before’ Falls Flat: A Frustratingly Slow Thriller on Apple TV+

0
255

Apple TV+ has just introduced its new thriller Before, starring Billy Crystal as Eli Adler, a child psychologist grappling with the grief of losing his wife, Lynn. While the promotional materials tout the series as “atmospheric,” the reality is a frustratingly stagnant viewing experience that leaves much to be desired.

A Lack of Momentum

The 10-episode season struggles with pacing, even with many episodes clocking in at under 25 minutes. Unfortunately, this brevity does not translate to excitement; instead, it leads to repetitive setups and themes that feel more like filler than substance. In a series format, an atmospheric approach without momentum often results in a tedious experience.

Crystal’s Performance Misses the Mark

Billy Crystal, known for his sharp wit, stars as Eli, whose life takes a turn when he meets Noah, an 8-year-old boy with troubling visions. Crystal’s portrayal is surprisingly devoid of the sardonic charm that fans expect. Although the character begins as a skeptical figure, his development quickly stagnates, leading to endless, identical exchanges with Noah that fail to evolve.

Repetition and Underdevelopment

The show is plagued by repetitive character dynamics. Noah, played by Jacobi Jupe, cycles through the same emotional beats: he hallucinates, trembles in fear, and disturbs those around him. Meanwhile, Rosie Perez, as Noah’s foster mother Denise, is relegated to a one-note role filled with panic. Judith Light, portraying Eli’s deceased wife, is barely more than a haunting memory, serving as a symbol of guilt rather than a fully realized character.

As Eli spends more time with Noah, he begins to experience his own supernatural disturbances, most notably the unsettling sound of dripping water. However, as the series progresses, the pacing becomes so drawn out that viewers may find themselves identifying too closely with Eli’s frustration and agony.

A Disjointed Narrative

The clues about Noah’s condition are few and far between, leading to a climax that feels disconnected from the preceding episodes. For instance, Noah inexplicably speaks in Dutch, a plot point that is quickly forgotten. Similarly, the sudden introduction of Lynn’s ex-boyfriend as a significant character feels jarring and unearned.

Rather than developing Eli’s relationship with his daughter or exploring the psychological elements of the story, Before opts for confusion and stagnation, leaving viewers with more questions than answers.

Final Thoughts

Despite its atmospheric intentions, Before fails to deliver a coherent and engaging narrative. The series could have capitalized on Eli’s skepticism toward the supernatural or his strained family relationships, but instead, it ends with a lackluster conclusion that sheds little light on its characters.

The first two episodes of Before are now available to stream on Apple TV+, with new episodes releasing weekly on Fridays. For those looking for a gripping thriller, you may want to set your sights elsewhere.

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here